Well, I've got over 500 through my new 16 gauge since last Friday, and although some of them were heavy for me, they shot very well.
The load I settled on for targets however, is 18.5 grains of PB in a Federal case, with a BPI SG16 wad and 7/8oz of shot.
This is a very mild load that let's me shoot the gun without discomfort.
By that , I mean that this particular gun weighs the same as my 28 gauge side lock SXS ( 5.8lbs.), and a 7/8 oz load moving at better than 1,200PFS REALLY let's you know it's on its way!
It's as good a shooter as my best 20 I have and my 28, but all three of these guns were built to my specs so switching from one to another is not a problem.
The 20 however, is a bit heavier , as it is actually built on a double rifle frame, so I can push a load faster with less discomfort than my 16 .
I doubt however, that most people would find that little 16 of mine terrible to shoot, it's just that I can't handle recoil to any great extent.
hand loading in any gauge can get you into custom ammo which is not always available, and with weird gauges like the 16 and the 28, a real big savings can be realized if you shoot a lot.
Cat