Pros & Cons - 3.5" 12 ga. options

[SwampShark]

I'm looking to buy a 3.5" 12 ga. pump. This will be my first shotgun so I'm not very familiar with them. I've only shot a Moss 500 before. I'm looking for an all-around shotgun assuming that this will be my only one. Slugs are not important. I want this gun for bird and waterfowl of all kinds, clays/target and SHTF reliability and longevity.

I've got it narrowed down to:
Moss 535 ATS
Rem 870 in 3.5
Benelli Nova

I'm not looking for brand preference comments but actual specifics that might help me make a decision. Also, please don't suggest any guns over $500. I'm sure they might be better, but I won't consider it. And yes, I will go and shoulder them all before buying.

Thanks in advance for your help!

Happy shooting!

[Cowtown guy]

The Benelli would be my choice.

[colroggal]

Originally Posted by Cowtown guy

The Benelli would be my choice.

I second the benelli. I prefer 870's because of the fit, but the 870 super mag is not the same internally as an 870 3". There have been some issues with them in the past.

I have no experience with the 535

Colin

[cody c]

Just a question, not a suggestion, but what about the remington 887?

[Yycadm]

I'm a bit curious; is 3.5in. chambering an absolute must have, or a "want to have"?

[wildside2014]

I have to ask, and don't take this as derailing because that's not the intent....but why on earth buy a 3.5??????? Or are you looking more for the ability to one off use a 3.5 shell while consistently using 3"?

[dbilyea]

I have a Mossburg 535. I love it. Pretty accurate and it will really reach out there with the 3.5". Your shoulder does get a little tired of it. Well worth the money for the price.

[Ithaca Dog]

3.5 inch shells kill more cleanly and farther out. More pellets mean more hits mean more birds. Pattern your shotgun to find your guns best load and shell.

Resale is usually better with 3.5 inch shells

That's it for the positive

Negative.
They hurt. Recoil sucks.
The shells are expensive.
Your gun is heavier


I wish I would have stayed with a 3" gun. I rarely shoot over 40 yards. I always patterned my gun and had good patterns because of it. I killed lots of birds with my smaller 12 ga. I usually shoot 3" shells out of my 3.5" gun now.

But.... I have the option. On a pass shoot or on birds that don't want to commit and flare I move to the big shells and do well. I have shot lots though and shoot in the off season. This is essential for making it worth it.

Most waterfowlers don't shoot well enough to make it worth it in my opinion.

Oh. And buy the Bennelli.